Istoriya al'ternativnykh techenij v planetnoj kosmogonii (gomogennaya ili geterogennaya akkretsiya) %t The history of two alternative concepts in planetary cosmogony (homogeneous of heterogeneous accretion)

NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS)

Rezanov, I. A.

Initially the hypotheses of Kant, Laplace, and other authors implied homogeneous accretion of planets from uniform material. O. Yu. Schmidt shared this idea. The idea of heterogeneous accretion was proposed in the mid-1940s by V. G. Fesenkov, who demonstrated that the iron cores of planets started to form prior to their silicate mantles. The obvious increase in average planet density with decreasing distance from the Sun suggests that the protoplanetary nebula was also heterogeneous - iron concentrated closer to the Sun, probably under the effect of its magnetic field. In the second half of the 20th century, planetary cosmogony developed against the background of continuous dispute between the adherents of homogeneous and heterogeneous planetary accretion. The confrontation still exists, although arguments in favour of heterogeneous accretion increase in weight. The dilemma under discussion is directly related to modern tectonic concepts, because it is necessary to find an answer to the question whether the core originated from the differentiation of the Earth's material or our planet had a core from the beginning.